EV vs ICE: 2025 Cost, Range & Performance Comparison

The debate between Electric Vehicles (EVs) and Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) cars has reached a critical point in 2025, with potential buyers facing more choices than ever before.

While government policies push towards electrification, many drivers remain uncertain about which technology best suits their needs and budget.

The decision involves more than just environmental considerations – it's about practicality, economics, and the future of personal transportation.

As Professor Colin Herron explains in our detailed analysis:

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"Once you've got an EV, you don't have range anxiety. You have range awareness."

Understanding the real-world differences between these technologies is crucial for making an informed decision about your next vehicle purchase.

What the Article Contains

Cost Analysis: Upfront vs Long-term Savings
Charging Infrastructure vs Fuel Stations
Range, Performance and Real-World Usage
Maintenance, Reliability and Ownership Experience
Environmental Impact and Future Considerations
Which Should You Choose?

We've analyzed real owner experiences, expert opinions, and current market data to provide you with a comprehensive comparison.

Cost Analysis: Upfront vs Long-term Savings

The most immediate difference between EVs and ICE vehicles is the purchase price, with EVs typically commanding a 20-40% premium over equivalent ICE models.

However, this upfront cost difference has been narrowing significantly, with new EV prices becoming more competitive and government incentives helping bridge the gap.

New EVs like the Kia e-Niro, Hyundai Kona Electric, or Volkswagen ID.3 offer substantial range and cutting-edge features, with many available through attractive finance packages that reduce the monthly cost impact.

The financial equation changes dramatically when considering running costs, where EVs demonstrate clear advantages in fuel and maintenance expenses.

Running Cost Breakdown

New EV owners consistently report dramatic fuel savings. One driver shared their experience: "I do an 80 mile round trip commute, went from spending £300 a month on petrol to £50 a month on electricity charging overnight at home at 7p kWh."

Home charging typically costs 2-4p per mile, compared to 12-15p per mile for petrol or diesel. However, public charging can cost similar to fuel, making home charging capability essential for maximum savings.

As Professor Colin Herron notes:

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"Charging takes 10 seconds of my time. I plug in, go to bed, and wake up full."

Insurance and Hidden Costs

Insurance costs can vary significantly, with some EVs commanding higher premiums due to expensive parts and specialist repair requirements. Tesla models, for example, often fall into high insurance groups.

Many EV owners report lower insurance costs when purchasing new vehicles with comprehensive safety packages and the latest driver assistance technology.

Additional EV costs include home charger installation (£750-£1,200) but this investment typically pays for itself within 1-2 years through cheaper home charging rates.

Charging Infrastructure vs Fuel Stations

The charging infrastructure debate often dominates EV discussions, but the reality varies significantly based on individual circumstances and usage patterns.

For drivers who can charge at home, the convenience factor strongly favors EVs – no more petrol station visits for daily driving.

Public charging has expanded rapidly, though quality and availability remain inconsistent across different regions and network operators.

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"The problem isn't the number of chargers, it's that we've put them in the wrong places."

Home Charging Reality

The ability to charge at home fundamentally changes the EV ownership experience. Most EV owners do 80-90% of their charging at home, making range anxiety largely irrelevant for daily use.

Urban dwellers without driveways face the biggest challenges, though workplace charging and rapid charging networks are expanding to address this gap.

Some EV owners manage with standard three-pin charging, adding 8-10 miles of range per hour, though dedicated home chargers provide 25-30 miles per hour and access to cheaper overnight tariffs.

Long-Distance Travel

Rapid charging networks have transformed long-distance EV travel, with 150kW+ chargers capable of adding 200+ miles in 30 minutes for compatible vehicles.

However, journey planning remains more complex than with ICE vehicles, requiring consideration of charging stops, weather conditions, and charger availability.

Professor Colin Herron observed during recent testing:

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"We just charged to 85% in 25 minutes. No queuing, no drama. So much for 'There aren't enough chargers.'"

Range, Performance and Real-World Usage

Range anxiety remains a primary concern for potential EV buyers, though real-world usage patterns suggest this worry is often overblown.

Modern EVs typically offer 200-300 miles of real-world range, sufficient for most daily driving needs. The average UK driver covers 37 miles per day, well within any EV's capability.

However, advertised ranges can be optimistic, with real-world figures often 10-20% lower, particularly in winter conditions when range can drop by 20-30%.

Performance Advantages

EVs offer instant torque delivery, providing immediate acceleration that ICE vehicles cannot match. This characteristic makes EVs feel more responsive in everyday driving situations.

The quiet operation of EVs creates a more relaxing driving environment, reducing fatigue on longer journeys and improving the audio experience for music and calls.

Air conditioning doesn't noticeably impact performance in EVs due to their abundant power reserves, unlike ICE vehicles where AC can reduce acceleration significantly.

Winter Performance Reality

Winter performance represents the biggest challenge for EV ownership, with cold weather affecting both range and charging speeds.

However, EVs offer unique winter advantages: instant cabin heating without engine warm-up, pre-conditioning while plugged in, and the ability to defrost the car remotely.

One EV owner noted: "Heated air in the cabin is immediate, as opposed to the several minutes of waiting for warm air to appear in my previous ICE car."

Maintenance, Reliability and Ownership Experience

EVs fundamentally differ from ICE vehicles in their maintenance requirements, with fewer moving parts and no oil changes, spark plugs, or exhaust systems to service.

Typical EV service intervals extend to 18-24 months or 15,000+ miles, compared to annual services for most ICE vehicles.

However, when repairs are needed, they often require specialist knowledge and parts, potentially increasing costs and wait times.

Battery Longevity Concerns

Battery replacement costs dominate EV reliability discussions, though real-world data suggests these fears are largely unfounded.

Most modern EVs come with 8-year, 100,000-mile battery warranties, and studies show batteries typically retain 80%+ capacity after 8 years.

As Professor Colin Herron emphasizes:

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"EV batteries aren't dying. They're outliving the cars."

Safety Considerations

Fire safety concerns about EVs persist despite evidence showing they're statistically safer than ICE vehicles.

Professor Colin Herron addresses this directly:

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"EVs don't catch fire more than petrol cars. That's just another myth. They're actually safer."

Daily Ownership Experience

EV owners consistently report higher satisfaction levels, with many stating they wouldn't return to ICE vehicles.

The convenience of home charging, quiet operation, and instant acceleration create a fundamentally different driving experience.

However, ownership requires adapting to new routines around charging and trip planning, which some drivers find challenging initially.

Environmental Impact and Future Considerations

Environmental considerations increasingly influence vehicle purchasing decisions, though the complete picture involves more than just tailpipe emissions.

EVs produce zero local emissions, improving air quality in urban areas and reducing noise pollution significantly.

However, electricity generation methods and battery production create environmental impacts that vary by region and manufacturer.

Grid Capacity and Renewable Energy

Concerns about grid capacity often arise in EV discussions, though energy experts consistently affirm the grid's ability to handle EV adoption.

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"The UK grid can handle the EV transition. National Grid says so, and that's good enough for me."

Resale Value Considerations

New EV depreciation has been steep initially, though this trend is stabilizing as the market matures and technology proves reliable. New EV buyers benefit from full manufacturer warranties, the latest technology, and potential government incentives.

Future resale values remain promising as charging infrastructure expands and EV technology becomes mainstream, with early adoption of proven platforms likely to retain value better.

New ICE vehicles face increasing uncertainty regarding future value, particularly with expanding low emission zones and potential policy changes affecting combustion engine ownership costs.

Which Should You Choose?

The choice between EV and ICE depends on individual circumstances, driving patterns, and priorities.

EVs excel for drivers who can charge at home, have predictable daily routines, and prioritize low running costs and environmental benefits.

ICE vehicles remain advantageous for high-mileage drivers, those without home charging options, or drivers who frequently undertake long journeys without planning flexibility.

EV is Right for You If:

You can install home charging or have reliable workplace charging
Daily driving is typically under 100 miles
You prioritize low running costs and environmental impact
You value quiet, smooth driving experience
Long journeys are infrequent or you're comfortable with planning charging stops

ICE Remains Better If:

You regularly drive 300+ miles without stopping
Home charging isn't possible and public charging is limited in your area
You need maximum flexibility for spontaneous long trips
Upfront cost is the primary concern regardless of running costs
You drive fewer than 5,000 miles annually

Expert Recommendation

Professor Colin Herron offers practical advice for undecided buyers:

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"If you're thinking about switching to an EV, don't listen to me. Go have a pint with someone who owns one."

Market Trends and Future Outlook

The automotive market is transitioning rapidly, with most manufacturers committing to electrification by 2030-2035.

This transition suggests EVs will become increasingly mainstream, with improved technology, expanded charging infrastructure, and competitive pricing making new EVs more attractive.

For those considering new vehicle purchases in 2025, the latest EV models offer cutting-edge technology, comprehensive warranties, and the confidence of buying proven, mature electric platforms.

Dr Colin Herron

Professor of Practice at Newcastle University

"At some point, EV adoption becomes social. When 3 out of 4 people in the pub drive one, you will too."

Conclusion

The EV vs ICE debate reflects a automotive industry in transition, with both technologies offering distinct advantages depending on individual needs and circumstances.

While EVs demonstrate clear benefits in running costs, environmental impact, and driving experience for suitable users, ICE vehicles retain advantages in flexibility, infrastructure maturity, and upfront costs.

The decision ultimately depends on honest assessment of your driving patterns, charging capabilities, and priorities. As the market continues evolving, the choice will likely become clearer as EV technology matures and infrastructure expands.

Whether you choose electric or combustion, the most important factor is selecting a new vehicle that meets your practical needs, comes with comprehensive warranty coverage, and fits your financial situation.

Motorfinity

At Motorfinity, we pride ourselves on offering exclusive discount across all makes and models.

Whether you're looking for efficiency, style, or cutting-edge technology, our selection is designed to meet every need.

You can choose from Personal Contract Purchase (PCP), Hire Purchase (HP), and leasing deals.

Each option provides flexibility and benefits tailored to different driving habits and budgetary needs.

Are you eligible?

Our nation's Armed Forces, Veterans, Emergency Services, NHS, Police and Prison Services, the Education and Social Care sectors and more from our eligible audience.